Struggling to get responses from corporate prospects? You're not alone. In a recent webinar hosted by Imagine Canada's Grant Connect team, Finding Your Focus: Strategic Prospecting for Corporate Fundraisers, fundraising consultant Heather Nelson of BridgeRaise shared a practical framework for building corporate partnerships that actually get replies.
Here are eight takeaways from the session that nonprofit fundraisers can start using right away.
1. Start with alignment, not a list of companies
Before you build a prospect list, get clear on why a company should care about your organization. Nelson says that outreach often fails because there's no real connection between an organization's needs and a company's priorities.
"Outreach fails if it's a long list of companies that has no clear alignment between the organization that you're representing and the company's needs, desires... and if there's no clear reason to reach out."
A list of company names is just raw data. It only becomes a true prospect list once you identify a clear, mutual reason to connect. Shift your focus away from your financial need and onto how your cause helps the funder meet their own social impact, employee engagement, or business goals. That reason has to be about them, not just about you.
2. Know what companies are actually looking for
Nelson pointed to research showing the factors drives corporate partnership decisions:
- 91% of companies rank brand mission alignment as their top factor
- Employees often drive partnership decisions, whether as volunteers, ambassadors, or beneficiaries
- Geographic overlap matters. National companies tend to partner with national charities, and local companies look for local matches
Use these as filters when you're evaluating whether a company belongs on your list.
3. Build a focused value proposition, not a general pitch
Many organizations rely on a broad case for support that gets turned into an equally broad pitch deck. Nelson recommends narrowing your message to match a specific company's priorities instead.
If your organization runs multiple programs, she suggests building a distinct value proposition for each one, so you can lead with whichever is most relevant to a given company.
4. Score your prospects before you reach out
Once you know your value proposition, test each company against a short list of alignment questions:
- Do your employees or theirs overlap?
- Do you operate in the same region?
- Is there a media moment or personal connection you could use?
Answering yes to a few of these helps you prioritize who goes to the top of your pipeline.
Nelson's advice: move away from "they have money, we need money" thinking, and towards a more deliberate value alignment and relationship connect based process.
5. Aim to open a conversation, not close a deal
One of the biggest mistakes Nelson sees is fundraisers trying to make the full case for support in a single email.
"What good outreach actually does is start a conversation. It doesn't try in any way to close a proposal or win money."
The goal of a first email is a next step, such as a short meeting or a quick answer to a specific question, rather than an immediate yes.
6. Use a simple three-sentence structure
Nelson recommends testing this format for cold outreach:
- The hook: A researched, specific reason for reaching out (include a referral name if you have one).
- One line about your organization. Just enough context to move forward.
- A specific next step. A short meeting or an easy-to-answer question.
Short emails consistently outperform long ones, according to Nelson, because recipients are often skimming between meetings, not sitting down to read carefully.
7. Skip the full pitch deck on a first email
When asked whether to attach a sponsorship package to a cold email, Nelson advised against leading with a complete pitch deck.
Sending a heavy PDF right away can create unnecessary friction for busy corporate managers, often causing them to set the email aside where it gets buried. Instead, tailor your initial approach based on your organization's current brand recognition:
- Lesser-known organizations: Include a single-page "credibility sheet" featuring 1–2 high-impact metrics and logos of major existing funders to build immediate trust.
- Established organizations: Skip attachments on the first touchpoint and let a concise, personalized email carry the message.
- Full pitch decks: Hold detailed proposals back until after an initial discovery call, allowing you to customize the package directly to the funder's specific priorities.
8. Don't take silence personally, and don't rely on one channel
Ghosting happens to everyone, even with a well-aligned, well-written email. It doesn’t necessarily mean that your pitch failed. Internal corporate reviews are slow, multi-layered processes, making respectful persistence an essential part of professional fundraising. Nelson cited research showing it can take 11 or more touchpoints to secure a new commitment, and that up to 10 people may review a proposal before it's approved.
"Silence does not mean no. It can take 11 plus touchpoints to secure a new commitment... Up to 10 people may touch your proposal before it's approved."
Her suggestions for keeping momentum: follow up with something shorter if your first email was too long, try a smaller ask to get an easier yes, and go multi-channel: email, LinkedIn, and business phone number. LinkedIn research found that prospects exposed to a company's marketing on LinkedIn were 25% more likely to respond to a subsequent sales message from that company.
Bringing it together
Nelson's framework boils down to three steps: focus your list on companies with genuine alignment, define your reason for reaching out before you write anything, and follow up consistently once you do. As she put it to attendees:
"Less is more... fewer emails out, but that have better reasons for the outreach, is better."
This post is based on Imagine Canada's Grant Connect webinar, Finding Your Focus: Strategic Prospecting for Corporate Fundraisers, featuring Heather Nelson of BridgeRaise. Connect with Heather at: [email protected].